Search
Free Signup | Login
 

About SunnyForest
Investing ideas from Justin Forest Read more

View Justin Forest's profile on LinkedIn

About SunnyForest
Investing ideas from Justin Forest Read more

View Justin Forest's profile on LinkedIn

Search
Blog Admin
You must be logged in and have permission to create or edit a blog.
Sun Blog
BCE: Case Study of Stupid Greedy Investors
Location: BlogsSunny Blog    
Posted by: Justin Forest 11/25/2008 3:33 PM

 

The failure of the largest Leverage buy out deal for BCE or Canada's largest telecom company demonstrated just how greedy investors were.

Essentially the LBO group, led by the Ontario's Teachers Pension Plan, was to buy the company for $42.75 a shares in cash from shareholders.

What was insane was the crazy wild ride the investors were taken. The stock have been trading like a Yo-yo between $33 and $40 (all in CAD) resulting from uncertainty of the deal in midst of the financial crisis.

The shares of BCE have long traded between $25 - $30 for the last 5 years before the LBO deal.

Given the situation of the crisis and uncertainties of the deals, investors were still hanging on and HOPING that the deal will go through at $42.75.

BCE

What I am saying, why be so greedy? why not fold the chips away. Now that all is gone, for the greedy few, it's a hard lesson to pay for.

In 2007, BCE was paying $1.45 a year in dividends. The shares went up to $40 and hung around there for almost a year that's when the greed kicked in. Too many investors were just waiting for the deal to close to get the full price of $42.75.

What does this mean?

Scenario 1) If your avg cost is $25/share and you could get out at $40, You'll be making a gain of $15. Look at it this way, BCE is paying you 10 years of dividends upfront ($15/1.45).

Scenario 2) If your avg cost is $30/share and you could get out at $40, You'll be making a gain of $10. BCE is paying you 7 years of dividends upfront ($15/1.45).

Why bother holding on for the next year or so waiting to edge out the extra 4.75 a shares? It just makes no senses and bothers me to see how irrational investors can be. They were hoping to get the extra $2.75 within 6 to 12 months before the deal closes. In the mean time, the biggest financial crisis going on, AIG, Lehman, Merrill, Citigroup, CIBC and many others banks were facing difficulties and investors were standing tight thinking the deal will go through!

 

Permalink |  Trackback

Your name:
Title:
Comment:
Add Comment   Cancel 
Recent SunnyBlogs

Consumer Confidence Indicates Market Bottom
The Consumer Confidence Index (CCI) measures the level of optimism of consumers. It turns out that this indicator is a good long term contrarion indicator. In the past 40 years, the indicator managed to pinpoint 5 market bottoms since 1969. That's a whopping 5 out 5 times!...

Will the Swine Flu be a repeat of SARs in 2003
Back in early 2003, the world was hit by SARS (Severe Acute Respiratory Syndrome). What's interesting is the similarity of the the market environment to what we have today and the swine flu. In early 2003, the S&P 500 was running into its 3rd year of bear market. ...

We won't fall off another cliff...not in this round.
It looks like we may have just touched the bottom of Round 2 of this multi-year secular bear market. The first one was in 2003. Even though the last two secular bear markets (1930's & 1970's) the PE reached an all time low of around 7 times earnings. While, the current PE on the broad market is jus...

Investing Word of Wisdom from the Great Wise one
Hope this letter will calm the market. Pass it along. "THE financial world is a mess...So ... I’ve been buying American stocks. Why? ...

BCE: Case Study of Stupid Greedy Investors
The failure of the largest Leverage buy out deal for BCE or Canada's largest telecom company demonstrated just how greedy investors were. ...

Risks associated to ETFs
ETFs like Proshares and BetaPro in Canada have gotten more popular in the past year. Many of us have gotten rather concerned about the associated credit risk or counterparty risks when owning one of these ETFs. Morningstar recently reported what are some of the risks associated to trading ETFs. ...

Subprime Mortgage Crisis Explained
Most of us are still quite confused about the whole subprimed mortgage mess that got us into this global financial crisis today. Check out this presentation on Google Docs...it pretty much explains everything in cartoon. Cute!...

Think the China market is big, wait till you see the Infrastructure!
“Macquarie Infrastructure Company estimates that global infra spending will reach $30 trillion in the next two decades. The increasing popularity of the group has made for a wild rise -- earlier this year, amid growing fears of a global recession, the stocks got pummeled. “ ...

Contrarion Buy - Dell
I am glad the market in general has been giving such a doom and gloom view on Dell. Its stock price halved from $40 to $20 just 3 years ago. I think it’s great because it simply gives me the opportunity to buy into a good, if not great, company like Dell....

Warren Buffett's 4.5 billion bet on long-term index puts and what it means
Here's something interesting I found out in the 2007 Berkshire Hathaway annual report. By now, we all know Warren is a big bull in the stock market in the next 11 to 19 years. Looking by his actions, Berkshire sold puts on notional value of $35 billion. That's no chump change. It's a big bet! With ...
Tracking by GoogleAnalytics
Tracking by GoogleAnalytics